Everyone needs a cookie at some point. Take a look at our assortment below to find your favorite or try a new flavor. To inlcude a personalized note with your cookie order, e-mail us at carsonsdeli@yahoo.com after your order is complete.  Our cookie delivery is available throughout the USA, so place an order today!

Pick Two

Pick Two Special

Includes two boxes of 12 cookies, approx. 5 lbs total with FREE SHIPPING.  Only $27.99.

Click here to pick any two of your favorite varieties, one dozen each. Please add a comment during checkout to let us know which two varieties you'd like!

Which two varieties?

Chocolate chip

Includes two boxes of 12 cookies, approx. 5 lbs total with FREE SHIPPING.  $29.99.

The “All-American” cookie.  Enjoy these yourself or send to someone special.  We love these cookies so much, we may even bake them a bit too big. Oh well – more room for the chips! There’s no skimping on these. They definitely need to be washed down with a nice glass of cold milk.

Peanut butter fudge swirl

Includes two boxes of 12 cookies, approx. 5 lbs total with FREE SHIPPING. $29.99.

The best of the best, but that’s just our opinion. The swirled icing drizzled over this already amazing cookie keeps it moist and bendable, designed to cause you to pause and realize just how good life is. Just close your eyes and say…Mmmm. Please do not eat while driving.

White chocolate macadamia nut

Includes two boxes of 12 cookies, approx. 5 lbs total with FREE SHIPPING. $29.99.

This is the best kept secret to avoid marriage counseling. So, how mad is she? You will both actually feel better about life after the first bite. This is a rich tender cookie with plenty of roasted macadamia nuts, offset with sweet white chocolate drops. After one, reconciliation, after two, reaffirm you wedding vows, after three is none of our business. We are not responsible either.

Vanilla drop

Includes two boxes of 12 cookies, approx. 5 lbs total with FREE SHIPPING. $29.99.

Sink into our wholesome moist thick vanilla goodness. This cakey cookie is topped with vanilla icing and is the perfect companion with a cup of coffee or tea and a good book.

Butterscotch oatmeal

Includes two boxes of 12 cookies, approx. 5 lbs total with FREE SHIPPING. $29.99.

So wholesome, you’ll think you woke up on a farm. The texture and deep taste makes you feel ready to start your day. “Cookies for breakfast” is perfect to be washed down with milk. It’s better than cereal!

Molasses

Includes two boxes of 12 cookies, approx. 5 lbs total with FREE SHIPPING. $29.99.

Last one in the package? Not with these. You’ll be hooked on molasses now. These are done right by Carson’s Bakery. Folks, you will find yourselves with a mouthful of vivid flavors and perfect spices flowing through this soft, chewy cookie encrusted with sugar. Great with an extra bold coffee!!

Oatmeal Raisin

Includes two boxes of 12 cookies, approx. 5 lbs total with FREE SHIPPING. $29.99.

Seriously, the best oatmeal raisin cookie on the planet. These are the perfect level of spices of nutmeg and cinnamon, mixed with old fashioned oatmeal, and then loaded up with raisins. With a chewy inside, and crispy edges, they are close to being the best thing you have ever put in your mouth. Must be chased with a cream soda for full effect. Life is good!

Peanut Butter

Includes two boxes of 12 cookies, approx. 5 lbs total with FREE SHIPPING. $29.99.

An energizing cookie with all the texture and flavor you would expect. No skimping on the real peanut butter either. That’s how we produce such a profound flavor. Awesome when combined with any malt beverage or root beer.

Pumpkin

Includes two boxes of 12 cookies, approx. 5 lbs total with FREE SHIPPING. $29.99.

Better than pumpkin pie. It has all the spices and no need for a plate. Like whipped cream, the vanilla icing is the perfect smooth complement for this warm soft cookie. Matched with an IPA or hot cider, that’s autumn.

Fudge Brownie

Includes two boxes of 12 cookies, approx. 5 lbs total with FREE SHIPPING. $29.99.

Be prepared to lose it. This rich delicious double fudge cookie is soft and chewy in the middle, topped with chocolate frosting and sprinkled with crunchy chopped walnuts. WARNING: Causes vivid memories of Thanksgiving dinners. Please sit down while eating.

We bake these delicious cookies daily at our bakery in Lockport, NY.
Come visit us to try one or all of our flavors!